an important fact to remember about Jews is that they are fundamentally Orientals, most of them having lived in the Occident for less than 2,000 years in most cases.
This is my problem with the AS. They make crazy statements that undermine race realism. Continents are man-made inventions.
A better argument would be that Middle Easterns are a different race. But Orientals… seriously!?
If race follows continents, then race truly doesn’t exist. Would you say that Russians living east of Ural are Orientals? Would you say that the Eskimo-like tribes in northern Finland are Caucasian?
Take a look at these three picture. Which one doesn’t fit with the other two?



This also can’t be explained away by saying that I found an atypical picture. The AS can’t tell that Aryans like George Steinbrenner and Tim Geithner are not Jewish. JewWatch claims Nancy Pelosi (Italian), Pope John Paul II (Polish) and Rupert Murdoch (Anglo-Saxon) are Jewish. You’d think someone who pays so much attention to Jews would be able to tell who’s who. Is there any confusion about Obama’s African ancestry? Booker T. Washington’s? W.E.B. DuBois’s? (All just half black.)
The standard of race vs. ethnicity is really about how easy it is to tell someone. Race can never be confused even for mixed race people. Ethnicity could be figured out, but it’s much harder.
It could be argued that Jews are a different race if we count the Middle East as a separate race, but please, don’t say stupid things like, “All Asians are Orientals”.
Clearly Indians and Pashtuns, Persians and Koreans, Jews and Indonesians, Russians and Pacific Islanders are not all part of the same race.
Saying so makes race realists look ridiculous when they try to argue that race is real and not a social invention.
